were supposed to 和 should 含义辨析区分

What were supposed to be new proposals were in fact modifications of earlier ones.

本句中的were supposed to 是否可以改成should ? 如可,含义有何不同?



请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2019-11-01 16:25

这位网友可能想了解在使用上,二者如何选择?


be supposed to,这种应该是用于“义务(obligation)或职责(duty)”方面,这种义务或职责既可以是


1)别人或者法律法规强求你做的。比如你are supposed to(应该)抹桌子(因为你老师要求你这样做,或者是学校规定轮到你做了)。也可以是


2)你自愿地尽自己的义务和责任。比如你are supposed to(应该)和朋友去看电影(尽朋友的义务),但不得不在家做作业。


而should这种应该,则偏向于建议(suggestion)或好的主意(a good idea)。比如你should应该)抹桌子(因为桌子太脏)


希望对你有所启迪。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 2 个回答

曾克辉  
擅长:英语考试

be supposed to为“半助动词”,意义与情态动词should或ought to相同。be supposed to不宜拆分,常被视为习语,整体地当作助动词,后接动词原形一起构成句子的谓语(也有人称其为“复合谓语”)。夸克《英语语法大全》(P.193)将此类结构视为“半助动词”,摘录如下:

半助动词:be going to

3.14 半助动词包括一批动词习语,它们具有情态或体的意义,并由动词HAVE或BE引导;例如:

be able to; be bound to; be likely to; be supposed to; be about to; be due to; be meant to; be willing to; be apt to; be going to; be obliged to; have to

半助动词范畴的边界不明确:可以扩大到把be unable to, be unwilling to等否定习语也包括进去。……


请先 登录 后评论
曹荣禄  
擅长:动词用法,句法问题

你自己仔细体会词典(韦氏高阶)对be sopposed to的不同释义和例句,想想每个例句是否可以用should替换,替换后意义是否相同。

be supposed

: to be expected to do something

  • They are supposed to arrive tomorrow.

  • She was supposed to be here an hour ago.

  • The movie was supposed to earn a lot of money at the box office, but it didn't.

: to be intended or expected to be (something)

  • The party was supposed to be a surprise.

— used to show that you are angry or offended by something— followed by to + verb

  • Was that supposed to be funny? I thought it was quite rude.

  • “Well, you've done it again.” “What's that supposed to mean?” [=what do you mean by that comment?]

— used to say what someone should do — followed by to + verb

  • You are supposed to listen to your parents.

  • I'm supposed to clean my room before I go outside.

  • What are we supposed to do [=what should/can we do] in a situation like this?

  • Do what you're supposed to.

— used to say what someone is allowed to do — followed by to + verb

  • We were not supposed to leave the room.

  • Are you supposed to be here after the building has closed?

— used to indicate what people say about someone or something— followed by to + verb

  • She is supposed to be the best doctor in town. [=people say that she's the best doctor in town]

  • That breed of dog is supposed to be good with kids.

  • The word is supposed to be derived from Latin.

请先 登录 后评论
  • 0 关注
  • 1 收藏,7021 浏览
  • Long2019 提出于 2019-10-30 15:50

相似问题