2 现在分词作时间状语要不要用完成时

老师好!新版人教必修三18页有个习题:

From the North Pole, the traveller wrote a book about his experience and had it published the following year.

我填的是Having returned,但是我在网上查到了2个相关课件,答案是Returning

我在这个问题(https://www.cpsenglish.com/question/30042)中看到:“doing作状语,分词的动作和谓语动作在时间上有重叠或首位衔接。即分词动作结束了,紧接着谓语动作开始或发生,尽管分词的动作在谓语动作之前也不用having done. 只有在分词的动作的结束和谓语动词的发生或开始之间有相当一段时间空白,才需要和必须使用having done形式。照此判断,不会出错的”

按照这个说法,旅行者回来后不可能马上写书,这里就是要填Having returned,不能填Returning

1. 但课本不可能错吧。所以想和老师们求教答案。这里是不是两个答案都可以。

2. 上面提到的那个问题https://www.cpsenglish.com/question/30042,用了现在分词的完成时,原因是分词的位置吗?我查找了不少语法书例句,发现现在分词表时间,一般用在句首或句尾,放在句中的都是现在分词的完成时。

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2021-08-30 17:42

(1) Returning from the North Pole, the traveller wrote a book about his experience and had it published the following year.

填现在分词returning 作时间状语,相当于连词as soon as +he returned或者when he returend,即下面的句子:

As soon as he returned from the North Pole, the traveller wrote a book about his experience and had it published the following year.

The traveller wrote a book about his experience and had it published the following year as soon as he returned from the North Pole,

(2) Having returned from the North Pole, the traveller wrote a book about his experience and had it published the following year.

填现在分词Having returned 作时间状语,相当于连词after he had returned,即下面的句子:

After he had returned from the North Pole, the traveller wrote a book about his experience and had it published the following year.

(1) 现在分词完成体作时间状语表示,分词动作与后面句子语动词动作有相当长的一段时间间隔。

(2 )现在分词一般体作时间状语表示,分词动作与后面句子谓语动词动作是紧跟着发生的或者一前一后的发生。中间的时间间隔不长。

总结:根据句子意思:很显然是从北极回来后,写书的动作就紧跟着发生了,属于紧跟其后发生的动作,所以用现在分词一般体,不用完成体作时间状语。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

曹荣禄  
擅长:动词用法,句法问题

当事人旅行回来后,就开始着手写书,写书可能需要几个月的时间,但写书的开始可以与return的动作是衔接的。注意所谓首尾衔接指的是说话人心理上认为二个动作是衔接的。不要纠结二个动作之间是否有几个毫秒、几秒钟、几分钟的时间空白。你的句子中的主语外出旅行了几个月,回来后就着手写书。你不能苛求他一到家放下行李,不洗澡、不吃饭,立刻坐下来写书,你觉得这样才算是return和写书是首尾衔接的动作吗?那你就是机械专业人士了。这个句子的理解应该是回到家,稍作休整(可能是一两天),就开始写书。如果用并列句表示,句子如下:The traveler returned from the North Pole, wrote a book about his experience and had it published the following year. 三个谓语动作按照时间顺序依次发生。

请先 登录 后评论
  • 3 关注
  • 7 收藏,2271 浏览
  • 信天无雨 提出于 2021-08-30 15:25

相似问题