1 with 复合结构在后接不定式时省略 with 的用法与独立主格结构的区别

With a lot of work to do, he had to go to the office quite early.

上面是with复合结构做原因状语,如果改成独立主格结构,是否必须把原来宾语与宾补之间的关系复原成下面的形式:

A lot of work to be done, he had to go to the office quite early.

而不能用:

A lot of work to do, he had to go to the office quite early.

是这样吗?

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2018-11-09 00:21

with 复合结构即介词with后接复合宾语,即with+宾语+宾补。复合宾语中的宾语和宾补之间存在逻辑主谓关系。

with a lot of work to do 中,a lot of work 与 to do并不是逻辑主谓关系,所以不定式to do并不是宾语补足语,而是定语。所以with后接的不是复合宾语,而是带有不定式作定语的单宾语。所以,with a lot of work to do并不是with复合结构,而只是一个with+名词构成的普通介词短语。我注意到不少国内语法书和或英语辅导书将with a lot of work to do 归入with复合结构讨论,这是不恰当的,是对with复合结构的误解,属于概念不清。

同样的道理,独立主格结构的也是由二部分构成:逻辑主语(名词或代词)+逻辑谓语(现在分词、过去分词、不定式、形容词、名词、副词小品词、介词短语等)。二者之间必须是逻辑主谓关系。如果是被动的逻辑主谓关系,则逻辑谓语必须采用被动形式。

由此可知,A lot of work to do 并不是独立主格结构,因为二者之间是被动关系,但to do却没有采用被动不定式。这里的不定式是定语修饰work, 表示动宾关系。

A lot of work to do 是一个名词词组,不能做状语。

所以,网友的句子是with介词短语作状语,不是with复合结构作状语。

With a lot of work to do, he had to go to the office quite early.

如果不用介词短语,可改用现在分词短语作状语:

Having a lot of work to do, he had to go to the office quite early.

如果想用独立主格结构作状语,那么被动关系的逻辑谓语必须采用被动形式:

A lot of work to be done, he had to go to the office quite early.

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

陈才   - 英语教师
擅长:中考英语,词法问题

With a lot of work to do, he had to go to the office quite early.

改为独立主格结构应该是下面句子

A lot of work to do, he had to go to the office quite early.

由于有很多工作要做,他不得很早就去办公室。


请先 登录 后评论
  • 5 关注
  • 7 收藏,10569 浏览
  • 张学祥 提出于 2018-11-08 21:34

相似问题