3 spending on which 的用法疑问

Roughly half of its staff work in research and development, spending on which grew by 26% last year, to $3.4bn—more than the company generated in net profit.

在这句话中我认为正常的顺序是:on which spending grew...,但是这里为什么能将spending前置?这种用法是不是和 xxx of which/whom有相似性,但是也有使用环境的限制,就是of+关系代词或者这里的on which,必须是一个关系分句中某个名词的后置修饰语(如文中的spending?)

这篇文章出自经济学人,标题《China’s smartphone champion has triumphed where Apple failed》,在倒数2段,第3行。

谢谢老师,专家,网友的分享解答!

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2025-07-23 09:23

Roughly half of its staff work in research and development, spending on which grew by 26% last year, to $3.4bn—more than the company generated in net profit.

原句分析:which 是关系代词,指代先行词 research and development(研发)。句中的 spending 是名词,意思是开支,支出,开销on which 在此为后置定语修饰名词 spendingspending on which 在含义上相当于 spending on research and development(在研发上的支出)。

其实说成  on  which spending 也不是不可以,下面举H. W. Fowler  A Dictionary of ENGLISH USAGE 中的一个类似例子:

attachments-2025-07-JmNq8JzB687fcd456f4f0.png

“Besought”is the established past & p.p., though “beseeched”, on which the OED comment is merely “now regarded as incorrect”, still occurs, probably by inadvertence, & Milton has “beseecht”

句意:Besought 是(beseech)公认的过去式和过去分词形式。尽管 “beseeched” 仍有使用——《牛津英语词典》(OED)对其的评论仅是如今被视为不正确”——但这种用法可能是出于疏忽,此外,弥尔顿还用过 “beseecht” 这一形式。

分析:句中的on which the OED comment 也可说成 the OED comment on whichwhich指代beseeched,意思是《牛津英语词典》对 beseeched 的评论

原句大意:该公司大约有一半员工从事研发工作,去年研发支出增长 26%,达到到了34亿美元——这一数字超过了公司的净利润。

原句改写:Roughly half of its staff work in research and development, and spending on research and development grew by 26% last year, to $3.4bn—more than the company generated in net profit.

类似例子:下面的截图来自H. W. Fowler A Dictionary of ENGLISH USAGE

attachments-2025-07-HCOBR4nJ687fa611333f0.png

The only satisfactory rule, exceptions to which are very few, is this...

句意:唯一令人满意的规则(其例外情况极为罕见)是这样的……

分析:which 也是关系代词,指代前文的名词 ruleto which 在此作后置定语修饰名词 exceptions(所以 to which 置于 exceptions 后面),exceptions to which 在意义上相当于exceptions to the rule(这条规则的例外情况)。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

蒋学文   - 英语教师
擅长:英语

周老师的解答非常棒,学习了。我也举一个类似的例子(不如周老师的例子合适),仅供参考:

Colin was wounded in a car accident, after hearing which Mike shot over to see him in hospital. 柯林在车祸中受了伤,迈克闻此马上就去医院看他了。

which 指代主句 Colin was wounded in a car accidentafter hearing which 相当于 and affter hearing the news

请先 登录 后评论
  • 4 关注
  • 1 收藏,694 浏览
  • Solomon   提出于 2025-07-22 16:39